
For your company
Money & Vendors
Module · Demos are cheap, production is not
The Post-Pilot Scaling Check
Most AI pilots succeed and then quietly never ship. The demo works, the room applauds, and the thing dies somewhere between the slide deck and a system that runs on Monday. This module checks the five places pilots go to die: the success bar, the production owner, the integration debt, the economics at real volume, and whether your company can ever say stop.
What the five levels look like
Every dimension in this assessment is scored 1 to 5. This is what the levels mean, dimension by dimension. The graded report diagnoses where your own answers land and what to do about it.
Success bar was set
- 1No criteria
- 2Vague ambitions
- 3Set afterwards
- 4Number, soft
- 5Pre-agreed pass line
At the low end: A pilot with no success number is a demo with a budget. Write one measurable threshold this week, agreed by whoever would fund the rollout, before you read another result. What good looks like: A pre-agreed pass line is what makes a pilot a test rather than a performance. Keep it honest: if the bar is missed, say so out loud and stop.
Production owner named
- 1Nobody owns it
- 2Innovation team only
- 3Owner in name
- 4Owner, no capacity
- 5Owner with capacity
At the low end: Without a production owner, a successful pilot becomes an orphan. Name the operational owner now, while the pilot is still cheap to shape around what they can actually run. What good looks like: A production owner with real capacity is the single strongest predictor that a pilot ships. Protect their time; it is the asset, not the model.
Integration debt scoped
- 1Never assessed
- 2Assumed trivial
- 3Roughly scoped
- 4Mostly mapped
- 5Fully costed
At the low end: Unscoped integration is how a two-week win becomes a two-quarter slog. Walk the full path from real source system to real user before you commit a rollout date. What good looks like: A fully costed integration plan is rare and worth its weight. Revisit it as the surrounding systems change; integration debt accrues interest quietly.
Unit economics hold
- 1Never modelled
- 2Pilot costs only
- 3Rough scale guess
- 4Modelled, optimistic
- 5Modelled and stress-tested
At the low end: A pilot that ignores unit economics can scale straight into a loss. Build a simple cost-per-transaction model at target volume before the rollout conversation goes further. What good looks like: Stress-tested economics turn scaling from a leap of faith into a decision. Keep the model live against real usage; vendor pricing and volumes both move.
Kill discipline exists
- 1Never kill any
- 2Kill on paper
- 3Killed once, painful
- 4Kill when needed
- 5Routine, blameless kills
At the low end: If nothing ever gets killed, sunk cost is running your portfolio. Give this pilot an explicit stop condition tied to the success bar from question 1, and honour it. What good looks like: Routine, blameless kills are the mark of a company that scales the right things. That discipline is why your survivors are worth scaling.